Monday, December 6, 2010

Assessing Children

As teachers we know that it is important to assess our students.  We need to know what they entered the grade knowing and we need to know if progress is being made.  The problem therein lies with are we testing too much or too little?  Are we testing the right way? Should testing be individualized? I know through personal experience that students could understand a concept and the minute they hear the word exam, or assessment, they freeze and cannot function.  I remember I had a student who was so stressed out about city exams (he was already struggling) that he developed Alopecia (losing his hair). We need to assess our students but I think we rely too much on standardized exams.  I remember students who were at the top of the class and would do mediocre and kids who couldn't even read were passing exams because they guessed correctly.  I think we need to take everything with a grain of salt.  There needs to be a balance of state assessment, classroom assessment, and critical teacher evaluation of progress.


In Afghanistan, the Afghan war has destroyed the educational infrastructure, demolished school buildings, and has killed teachers.  There is a huge disparity between boys who go to schools and the number of girls.  Because of the Taliban, girls were not allowed to receive an education and currently the number of girls attending schools is lower than the number of boys who attend school.  Because of war, no records were available to assess students.  
http://www.unesco.org/education/wef/countryreports/afghanistan/rapport_1.html 


9 comments:

  1. Johan,

    I see that you and I both know that it is important to assess our students. I feel as though if a student is not capable of moving on to the next grade, why promote them. I totally disagree on something that's going on in MS school district that I'm going to bring out at the next PTA meeting because I don't think it's right. Too many tests DONOT solve problems they only create them.......

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Johan,
    I agree that many standardized tests do not accurately assess students’ abilities. I remember my daughter becoming physically ill prior to taking state wide assessments each spring. Luckily, she passed the 10th grade (final) assessment in 9th grade and so no longer needed to go through that stress. She is a bright and capable student, but the idea of one test-- one opportunity was very overwhelming to her.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Johan, it is very sad to hear about war torn countries like Afghanistan. These children are taught at a young age to abandon their education and prepare to train for war. I remember my husband sharing stories with me about young boys shooting at him. I can only hope and pray for peace soon...

    ReplyDelete
  4. I find it admazing how we still have counties today that continues to discriminate against women receiving an education. I'm a bit surprised that more boys are able to attend school since Afghans usually recruit young boys to be soldiers.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Johan,
    I agree, it is important to find a good balance when it comes to assessments! It is so unfortunate when so much emphasis is placed on a test especially when, as you point out, these tests are not accurate measurements! It is also heartbreaking to hear that not all children have the opportunity to learn and receive an education because of things beyond their control.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you for sharing the information on afganistan. It terrible that there are children out there who can't even get an education. It is also sad that girls are growing up in that country at a disadvantage and are not allowed to get the education that they deserve.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh my goodness that poor little boy. I guess we do forget how stressful testing can be on the little ones. Parents and society put so much pressure on children to be achievers tht it can certainly affect the outcome of the assessment. I agree, we absolutley should try to find a way to individualize the testing and make sure it accuratley reflects the different learning as well as tesing styles.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Johan,
    I wanted to say a great big THANK YOU for your support, encouragement, and positive attitude during this class! I appreciate all you have done fore everyone!
    Sincerely,
    Rhonda Richards

    ReplyDelete
  9. Johan,

    Thank You for everything.....I have really enjoyed reading your blogs and discussion. I'm looking forward to seeing you in our next class. Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.

    ReplyDelete